
I will never get tired of beating this drum. Never. So here it is again:
Federer is not as good as everything thinks he is.
In his ‘golden era’ he has basically had to contend with 2 good opponent. I think if I only had 1 other player on the entire tour capable of beating me (golden era remember) then I would win a few slams too.
Lets look over Federer’s ‘wins’ in Grand Slam finals, and everyone pay attention, because we are going to review these in-depth:
Wimbledon 2003 – Beats Mark Philippoussis
Verdict = He beat a serial loser to win a slam
Australian Open 2004 – Beats Safin
Verdict = I’m not saying anything, but maybe Safin had a big night on the town before the final?
Wimbledon 2004 – Beats Roddick
Verdict = A big serve and nothing else. A few weeks of practice and I could give Roddick a good game
US Open 2004 – Beats Hewitt
Verdict = Hewitt’s best year was behind him. Writing was on the wall for him by this point
Wimbledon 2005 – Beats Roddick (again)
Verdict = Same old Roddick, but with a slightly slower serve
US Open 2005 – Beats Agassi
Verdict = beat an ageing great in his last ever slam final. Again, not that impressive
Aussie 2006 – Beats Baghdatis
Verdict = Baghdatis is ok. Need I say more?
Wimbledon 2006 – Beats Nadal
Verdict = a good win. No denying Nadal is great.
US 2006 – Beats Roddick (again and again)
Verdict = Roddick with an even slower serve
Aussie 2007 0 Beats Gonzalez
Verdict = His only ever final. Gonzalez froze, let’s be honest
Wimbledon 2007 – Beats Nadal
Verdict = A good win again.
US Open 2007 – Beats Djokovic
Verdict = I have absolutely zero respect for Djokovic.
US 2008 – Beats Murray
Verdict = What a win. Federer had to produce the best tennis of his career by far to beat Murray. But lets not forget Murray had a 2 day epic on his hands to beat Nadal before getting to Federer. Had that not been the case the outcome of the final might have been very different.
French 2009 – Beat Soderling
Veridct = Nadal was injured
Wimbledon 2009 – Beat Roddick
Verdict = Roddick by now had no serve
Aussie 2010 – Beat Murray
Verdict = He got lucky, but still a great win
Summary:
Roger Federer has had four wins in his entire career that I consider ‘worthy’. Now…

Jimmy Connors:
8 Grand Sam wins. Let’s have a look at who he had to beat:
Ken Rosewall (8 Slams)
Phil Dent (A great player)
Bjorn Borg (11 Slams)
John McEnroe (7 Slams)
Ivan Lendl (8 Slams)
Now, look at that list and compare it to who Federer has had to play. Is there really any comparison? I didn’t think so.


























